Tuesday, 17 November 2026The Hindu

The Hindu – Important News Articles & Editorial

Today’s coverage: the Supreme Court on Aadhaar accessibility for blind users, the PM on ASEAN ahead of the Manila summits, divergent positions in the COP31 draft text, twenty years of the Sachar report, the debate over India’s poverty line, and an editorial on using multilateral fora for cooperation with Pakistan.

News 01 · Page 04GS II – Polity

SC warns of contempt over Aadhaar accessibility issues

The Supreme Court has warned of contempt action if the Centre and other authorities do not give a detailed response to an application on Aadhaar face authentication. The application says blind and low-vision persons still cannot independently complete face authentication, which blocks their e-KYC. The matter tests digital inclusion and the right to access.

Key Facts

  • Application: advocate Amar Jain says the Aadhaar app’s face authentication requires the eyes to be attentive and looking into the frame, which blind persons cannot do. A private bank rejected his e-KYC for a credit card in October 2026.
  • Alleged gaps: no grievance mechanism for accessibility complaints, and no visible accessibility audits, nodal officers, human review of rejected KYC or compliance monitoring.
  • Earlier ruling: Pragya Prasun v. Union of India (2025) gave directions to ease digital access for persons with disabilities; the application says they have not been fully implemented.
  • Authorities named: the Union government, RBI, MeitY, TRAI, DoT, SEBI, PFRDA and IRDAI.
  • Separate challenge: the mandate, from 1 October 2026, for biometric Aadhaar authentication for subsidised domestic LPG refills.
  • A Bench headed by Justice J.B. Pardiwala issued notice; the hearing is in four weeks.
Legal framework for accessible digital services
SourceWhat it provides
Articles 14, 21 and 41Equality, dignity and access to services; public assistance in cases of disablement
Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016Accessibility of the built environment, transport and ICT (Sections 40–46); grievance redress and non-discrimination
UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with DisabilitiesRatified by India in 2007; requires accessible ICT
K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar), 2018Aadhaar upheld, but benefits cannot be denied for lack of Aadhaar and alternatives must exist
Pragya Prasun, 2025Right to digital access read into Article 21

Static Dimensions

  • Aadhaar: governed by the Aadhaar Act, 2016; administered by UIDAI.
  • Reasonable accommodation: necessary and appropriate modifications that let persons with disabilities exercise their rights on an equal basis, defined in the RPwD Act, 2016.
  • Standards: Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) and the Guidelines for Indian Government Websites (GIGW); Accessible India Campaign (2015).

Analysis

  • Design that excludes: a face-based, eye-attentive check turns a technical limit into denial of services such as banking and credit.
  • Compliance gap: gaps across several regulators show that court directions need monitoring and accountability, not just issue.
  • Mandatory biometrics: making biometric authentication compulsory without an accessible alternative can deny entitlements, which conflicts with the Puttaswamy safeguard.

Challenges

  • No grievance redress or accessibility audits.
  • Weak enforcement across multiple regulators.
  • Systems designed without disabled users’ input.

Way Forward

  • Provide alternatives: assisted, voice, OTP or human-verified KYC.
  • Mandatory accessibility audits, nodal officers and complaint portals.
  • Involve disabled users in design and testing; time-bound compliance reports to the Court.

India Implications

  • Digital inclusion: as banking, welfare and subsidies move online, inaccessible authentication can lock out persons with disabilities.
  • Regulatory accountability: the case may push RBI, SEBI, IRDAI and others to adopt uniform accessibility standards for e-KYC.
  • Welfare delivery: mandatory biometric checks for subsidies need accessible alternatives built in.
ConclusionDigital India works only if it is accessible to all. Accessible design, alternatives and accountability turn the Court’s directions into practice.
Prelims Practice

Which of the following best describes the concept of ‘reasonable accommodation’ under disability rights?

  • (a) Providing identical facilities to all users irrespective of their needs
  • (b) Making necessary and appropriate modifications to enable persons with disabilities to exercise their rights on an equal basis
  • (c) Exempting public authorities from accessibility requirements
  • (d) Providing assistance only after a person has been denied a service
Click to reveal answer
Answer: (b) – Reasonable accommodation means adjusting systems so persons with disabilities can use them on equal terms – for example, offering an assisted or OTP-based alternative to face authentication.
Mains Practice

Examine how Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution can support the right of persons with disabilities to access digital public services. (10 Marks, 150 Words)

↑ Back to contents
News 02 · Page 04GS II – IR

Indo-ASEAN ties are at the heart of India’s Act East Policy, says PM ahead of Manila summit

Prime Minister Narendra Modi said India’s relationship with ASEAN is at the “heart of India’s Act East Policy” and central to the MAHASAGAR vision, ahead of the Manila summits. He is taking part in the 49th ASEAN Summit, the 23rd ASEAN-India Summit and the 21st East Asia Summit (EAS). A Quad leaders’ meeting is also expected, though it has not been officially announced.

Key Facts

  • PM’s message: ties are rooted in centuries of civilisational exchange and now span trade, connectivity, maritime security, technology and people-to-people links; the ASEAN-India summit will build on the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership.
  • Participants: the Philippine President hosted a gala dinner. Australia’s Prime Minister is attending as Australia is an ASEAN partner country. The U.S. President is expected, and will then go to Shenzhen for the APEC meeting.
  • Quad: a leaders’ summit of India, Japan, Australia and the U.S. is expected on Tuesday evening, according to The Hindu and sources; it has not been officially announced.
  • South China Sea: India maintains that it should remain open to global maritime traffic. Sources expect a constructive message from the Quad, since the Philippines is on the front line of territorial disputes; China’s structures and naval patrols worry its neighbours.
India and regional groupings
GroupingIndia’s status
East Asia Summit (2005)Member – the leaders-level Indo-Pacific forum
QuadMember, with Japan, Australia and the U.S.
BRICSFounding member
APEC (Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation)Not a member
ASEANComprehensive Strategic Partner (since 2022)

Static Dimensions

  • Act East Policy: launched in 2014, upgrading the 1992 Look East Policy; focuses on trade, connectivity, culture and strategic ties.
  • MAHASAGAR: Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions, announced in 2025; builds on SAGAR (2015).
  • ASEAN-India milestones: Sectoral Dialogue Partner (1992), full Dialogue Partner (1996), summit level (2002), Strategic Partnership (2012), Comprehensive Strategic Partnership (2022).
  • South China Sea law: UNCLOS (1982) and the 2016 arbitral award in the Philippines-China case; ASEAN-China Code of Conduct talks continue.

Analysis

  • Centrality both ways: supporting ASEAN centrality gives India a stake in the regional architecture without alliance commitments.
  • Maritime focus: MAHASAGAR links the Indian Ocean with the wider Indo-Pacific, with ASEAN as the bridge.
  • Quad and ASEAN: holding the Quad meeting alongside ASEAN summits signals the grouping works with ASEAN-led forums.
  • Freedom of navigation: India’s stress on UNCLOS reflects its trade interest, since much of its commerce passes through these waters.
  • Caution: the Quad meeting is only expected; outcomes will be known after the summits.

Challenges

  • Incomplete trade review and the trade deficit with ASEAN.
  • ASEAN’s consensus-based pace and diverse positions.
  • Maritime disputes and great-power competition.

Way Forward

  • Conclude the AITIGA review; deepen connectivity and maritime cooperation.
  • Support a rules-based Code of Conduct and compliance with UNCLOS.
  • Expand digital, education and tourism links.

India Implications

  • Indo-Pacific role: ASEAN partnership anchors India’s presence in the wider region.
  • Trade security: open sea lanes in the South China Sea protect a large share of India’s commerce.
  • Economic gains: the AITIGA review is the test of whether political warmth turns into trade benefits.
ConclusionASEAN is central to India’s Act East and MAHASAGAR visions. Delivery on trade, connectivity and maritime security will decide how far this partnership shapes a stable Indo-Pacific.
Prelims Practice

India is NOT a member of:

  • (a) East Asia Summit
  • (b) APEC
  • (c) BRICS
  • (d) Quad
Click to reveal answer
Answer: (b) – India is not a member of Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC), though it has long sought membership. It is a member of the East Asia Summit, BRICS and the Quad.
Mains Practice

Discuss how MAHASAGAR and the Act East Policy together shape India’s engagement with ASEAN. (10 Marks, 150 Words)

↑ Back to contents
News 03 · Page 06GS III – Environment

Divergent positions mark draft text of COP31 in Türkiye

Three reports point to one theme: how India’s green transition connects global rules, domestic delivery and industrial strategy. At COP31 in Antalya, the draft text shows divergent North-South positions. In Mumbai, the Earthshot Prize highlighted India’s clean-energy record. Meanwhile, India is targeting a top-10 global ranking in shipbuilding by 2030.

Key Facts

  • Net zero dates: developing countries (the LMDC group including India, the Arab Group, the African Group and LDCs) want developed countries to “lead” with net zero by 2030 and net negative emissions by 2045. Developed countries have mostly set 2050; India’s target is 2070 and China’s 2060.
  • Finance: the draft cover text calls on developing countries to “contribute voluntarily” to climate finance, which cuts against the UNFCCC’s developed-developing divide.
  • Trade and electrification: developing countries want measures like the EU’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) removed by the end of 2027, and “no obligation” on a Presidency-proposed goal of 35% of energy use from electricity by 2035.
  • U.S. absence: the U.S. has withdrawn from the Paris Agreement; the EU, U.K. and Japan carry developed-country positions.
  • Earthshot, Mumbai: India reached 50% non-fossil installed capacity five years early, and solar capacity grew over 50-fold in just over a decade (as stated by Prince William). Two Indian finalists – Mahila Housing Trust and Mahindra Last Mile Mobility – are among 15; five winners are to be announced on Tuesday. India has produced the most finalists and winners.
  • Shipbuilding: target of top 10 by 2030 and top 5 by 2047; about $10 billion projected in five proposed greenfield coastal clusters, including Dugarajapatnam in Andhra Pradesh.
COP31 draft: where the blocs differ
IssueDeveloping countries’ positionDraft text / developed-country position
Net zeroDeveloped countries to lead: net zero by 2030, net negative by 2045Most developed countries target 2050
Climate financeObligation lies with developed countriesDeveloping countries to “contribute voluntarily”
CBAMRemove such measures by end-2027EU’s CBAM continues
Electrification goal“No obligation”Presidency proposes 35% of energy from electricity by 2035

Static Dimensions

  • UNFCCC principles: Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC); Paris Agreement Article 9 on climate finance led by developed countries.
  • Net zero: a balance between emissions and removals; India’s 2070 target and 500 GW non-fossil capacity goal for 2030.
  • CBAM: an EU charge on carbon-intensive imports such as steel, seen by developing countries as a unilateral trade barrier.
  • Shipping and climate: the IMO aims for net-zero shipping around 2050; green fuels (methanol, ammonia, hydrogen) will shape future shipbuilding. India’s Maritime Amrit Kaal Vision 2047 and the shipbuilding support package back the target.

Analysis

  • Responsibility versus capacity: asking developing countries to contribute “voluntarily” to finance, while they demand faster net zero from developed countries, reopens the question of historical responsibility; India’s 2070 target rests on this principle.
  • Trade and climate overlap: CBAM and electrification targets show climate policy spilling into trade and industry, raising export costs for developing countries.
  • Delivery counts: India’s early non-fossil milestone strengthens its negotiating credibility, but capacity is not generation – storage, grids and finance remain gaps.
  • Industrial link: shipbuilding is a manufacturing, jobs and trade-security goal that can be low-carbon if clusters adopt green fuels and renewable power.
  • Caution: the COP31 text is a draft and will change; the Earthshot results and shipbuilding investments are projections.

Challenges

  • North-South trust deficit and finance gap.
  • Trade measures like CBAM.
  • Grid and storage limits.
  • Large capital needs for shipyards.

Way Forward

  • Insist on CBDR-RC, grant-based finance and predictable support.
  • Negotiate relief or flexibility on CBAM.
  • Link shipbuilding clusters to green-fuel and renewable infrastructure.
  • Scale up grassroots innovations such as those honoured by Earthshot.

India Implications

  • Negotiating stance: India must defend CBDR-RC while showing delivery at home.
  • Exports: CBAM and similar measures could raise costs for Indian steel and aluminium.
  • Industrial strategy: green shipbuilding links climate goals with manufacturing and jobs.
ConclusionIndia’s position is stronger when its negotiating stand is backed by delivery on clean energy and a credible industrial plan. Climate justice abroad and green growth at home need to move together.
Prelims Practice

With reference to the principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC), consider the following statements:

  1. It recognises that all countries share responsibility for addressing climate change.
  2. It acknowledges differences in historical contributions and respective capabilities.
  3. It places identical emission-reduction obligations on all countries.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 2 and 3 only
  • (c) 1 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Click to reveal answer
Answer: (a) – CBDR-RC means all countries share the responsibility to act, but obligations differ according to historical emissions and capacity. It does not impose identical targets, so statement 3 is incorrect.
Mains Practice

The debate over climate finance and differentiated emission-reduction responsibilities reflects the persistent trust deficit between developed and developing countries. Analyse the issue in the context of CBDR-RC and the Paris Agreement. (10 Marks, 150 Words)

↑ Back to contents
News 04 · Page 10GS II – Governance

The Sachar report awaits its due

The Sachar Committee (the Prime Minister’s High-Level Committee on the Social, Economic and Educational Status of Muslims) submitted its report on 17 November 2006, and it was tabled in Parliament on 30 November 2006. Twenty years on, the author argues that its general recommendations remain unimplemented.

Key Facts

  • Scope: data on population, education, employment, banking, infrastructure, poverty and share in government jobs.
  • Finding: deficits and deprivation across most development indicators; it recommended “inclusive development” and “mainstreaming”.
  • Implemented: pre-matric and post-matric scholarships and the Multi-Sectoral Development Programme.
  • Not implemented: the National Data Bank, the Equal Opportunity Commission and the Diversity Index.
  • Author’s view: the report should be placed again before Parliament and discussed.
Sachar recommendations: status after 20 years
RecommendationStatus (as per the article)
Pre-matric and post-matric scholarshipsImplemented
Multi-Sectoral Development ProgrammeImplemented; later restructured as the Pradhan Mantri Jan Vikas Karyakram
National Data BankNot implemented
Equal Opportunity CommissionNot implemented
Diversity IndexNot implemented

Static Dimensions

  • Constitutional basis: Articles 14, 15, 16, 21, 29, 30 and 46; the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992.
  • Follow-up bodies: Ministry of Minority Affairs (2006); Ranganath Misra Commission (2007, recommended reservation for minorities); Kundu Committee (post-Sachar evaluation); the Prime Minister’s 15-Point Programme.
  • Schemes: minority scholarships and the Multi-Sectoral Development Programme, later restructured as the Pradhan Mantri Jan Vikas Karyakram.

Analysis

  • Evidence-based diagnosis: the report’s value lies in using data rather than perception.
  • General recommendations: the equal opportunity framework, diversity index and data bank apply to all deprived groups, fitting the idea of inclusive growth.
  • Limited reach of targeted schemes: structural gaps in education, credit and jobs need sustained, area-based action.
  • Other view: critics of community-specific targeting argue that welfare should be needs-based and universal rather than linked to religion; the report’s general recommendations, which cover all groups, partly address this concern.

Challenges

  • Limited data on group-wise outcomes.
  • Weak monitoring of schemes.
  • Balancing targeted support with universal programmes.

Way Forward

  • Build a regular socio-economic data system with a diversity measure.
  • Evaluate past schemes independently; focus on education, skills, credit access and public services.
  • Integrate with general inclusion programmes for all disadvantaged groups.

India Implications

  • Data for policy: regular group-wise socio-economic data helps target welfare to whoever is lagging.
  • Inclusive growth: persistent gaps in education, credit and jobs among any group hold back overall development.
  • Accountability: independent evaluation of schemes shows what works.
ConclusionThe report’s lasting lesson is that equitable development needs credible data, regular review and delivery. Treating its data-driven approach as a continuing tool can help reduce disparities.
Mains Practice

Despite several welfare initiatives, structural inequalities in education, employment and access to credit persist among disadvantaged communities. Analyse the reasons and suggest measures to address these gaps. (10 Marks, 150 Words)

↑ Back to contents
News 05 · Page 09GS I, II & III – Society, Social Justice & Economy

A poverty line that falls short

Poverty in India has clearly fallen over the past decade, but estimates of how many remain poor range from about 5% to over 26%. The author argues that this spread comes mainly from where the line is drawn and how it is built, not from disagreement over the trend, and calls for a new official poverty line backed by credible data.

Key Facts

  • World Bank: 2.6% poor at the $3-a-day extreme poverty line (2021 PPP); about 16.1% at $4.20, the lower-middle-income benchmark. 80% of Indians lived below the $8.3-a-day upper-middle-income line in 2023.
  • Data gap: the 2017-18 consumption survey was not published; the next full survey was the 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES).
  • Multidimensional poverty: NITI Aayog’s index fell from 24.85% (2015-16) to 14.96% (2019-21); the 11.28% figure for 2022-23 is a projection, not a fresh survey result. The World Bank puts it at 15.5%, and OPHI at 16.4% for 2019-21.
  • Other gaps: 30% of Indians lack access to basic sanitation.
Why poverty estimates differ: the line decides the level
EstimatePoverty shareBasis
World Bank, $3 a day2.6%International extreme poverty line (2021 PPP)
SBI Research7.2% rural, 4.6% urban (2022-23)Tendulkar line adjusted for inflation: about ₹1,632 rural and ₹1,944 urban per person per month
Rangarajan and Dev10.8%Updated Rangarajan line
World Bank, $4.20 a day16.1%Lower-middle-income benchmark
Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024)26.4%Line rebuilt from current spending: ₹2,515 rural and ₹3,639 urban
World Bank, $8.3 a day80% (2023)Upper-middle-income benchmark
History of India’s official poverty lines
CommitteeYearApproach
Dandekar-Rath1971Early calorie-based estimate
Alagh Task Force1979Calorie norms
Lakdawala1993State-specific lines
Tendulkar2009Wider basket including health and education; about ₹816 rural and ₹1,000 urban per person per month in 2011-12; 21.9% poor
Rangarajan2014About ₹972 rural and ₹1,407 urban; 29.5% poor in 2011-12

Static Dimensions

  • Concepts: absolute versus relative poverty; headcount ratio (share below the line) and poverty gap (depth); consumption-based versus income-based measurement; Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) dollars for international comparison.
  • Multidimensional Poverty Index: the global MPI (UNDP-OPHI) covers health, education and living standards; India’s national MPI (NITI Aayog) uses 12 indicators, including sanitation, drinking water, housing, electricity and bank accounts.
  • Linked policy: SDG 1; targeted welfare such as the PDS under the National Food Security Act; the National Statistics Office (NSO) as the data source.

Analysis

  • Line first, level second: the gap between 5% and 26% comes mostly from thresholds – higher lines give higher poverty. The estimate rests on a normative choice about what counts as a decent minimum.
  • Method matters: one approach adjusts an old line for inflation; the other rebuilds the line from the latest spending pattern. With more non-food spending today, an old basket may not reflect current needs.
  • International versus national lines: World Bank PPP lines allow cross-country comparison but are not built on an Indian basic-needs basket – useful for ranking, not for targeting policy.
  • Data vacuum: with no comparable official survey for over a decade, researchers used assorted lines; the 2022-23 HCES offers a fresh base, but an official line must still be set.
  • Consumption versus MPI: consumption measures miss access deprivations like sanitation, while MPI misses income shortfalls; together they give a fuller picture.
  • Inequality behind averages: 80% below $8.3 a day suggests a low extreme-poverty figure hides deep vulnerability to falling back.
  • Why it matters: the line shapes who is targeted, budget needs and how progress is judged.
  • Caution: this is one economist’s view; estimates from different methods should not be compared as if they measured the same thing.

Challenges

  • No official updated poverty line.
  • Irregular survey data and breaks in comparability.
  • Differences in measuring consumption and prices across rural-urban areas and States.
  • Gaps in non-income deprivations such as sanitation.

Way Forward

  • Appoint an expert group to set an official line using the 2022-23 HCES and a current basket, with State-wise price indices.
  • Release surveys at regular intervals with consistent methods.
  • Report consumption poverty, MPI and a vulnerability measure together.
  • Use disaggregated data to target schemes and close sanitation and service gaps.

India Implications

  • Welfare targeting: an outdated line can include or exclude the wrong households.
  • Budgeting: the number of poor drives allocations for food, housing and social security.
  • Credibility: a transparent official line makes claims of progress verifiable.
ConclusionPoverty in India has fallen, but a credible benchmark is needed to know by how much and what remains. A transparent official line, regular data and multiple indicators will turn arguments over numbers into better policy.
Prelims Practice

With reference to poverty estimation in India, consider the following statements:

  1. The Tendulkar Committee moved away from calorie norms and included spending on health and education in its basket.
  2. For 2011-12, the Rangarajan method estimated a higher poverty ratio than the Tendulkar method.
  3. NITI Aayog’s national Multidimensional Poverty Index is based solely on household consumption expenditure.

Which of the statements given above are correct?

  • (a) 1 and 2 only
  • (b) 2 and 3 only
  • (c) 1 and 3 only
  • (d) 1, 2 and 3
Click to reveal answer
Answer: (a) – Tendulkar used a wider basket including health and education, and Rangarajan’s higher line gave 29.5% against Tendulkar’s 21.9% for 2011-12. The national MPI uses 12 non-income indicators such as sanitation, housing and schooling, not consumption, so statement 3 is incorrect.
Mains Practice

“Poverty estimation is not merely a statistical exercise; it influences welfare targeting, budgetary allocation and assessment of development outcomes.” Discuss. (10 Marks, 150 Words)

↑ Back to contents
Editorial Analysis · Page 08Editorial – GS II – IR

Editorial: Clear the path – India should use multilateral fora to advance bilateral cooperation

Pakistan’s climate minister is set to attend the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum in New Delhi. The editorial argues that India can keep its firm position on cross-border terrorism while identifying areas, such as water and climate, where cooperation with Pakistan serves Indian interests. It is an opinion piece; the Indian government’s stated position is that terrorism and talks cannot coexist.

Key Facts

  • India’s position: since the Pahalgam attack and the confrontation that followed, India holds that terrorism and bilateral talks cannot go together, and has extended this condition to trade and water.
  • Regional context: South Asia’s intra-regional trade is only about 5%, and strained ties have created diplomatic space that China uses through trilateral and regional groupings (as per Chatham House, cited in the editorial).
  • SCO: India hosts SCO events, and Pakistan, as chair, is hosting the August 2027 Islamabad Summit; the editorial sees both as pragmatic.
  • Water: India stopped sharing routine Indus hydrological data and approved the Chenab-Beas link tunnel; the Pakistani minister made a hostile remark about “cutting off hands”. China has restricted Brahmaputra data while building the Medog dam, and India has protested Bangladesh’s proposed Padma Barrage.
  • Argument: suspending ties signals resolve but does not reduce terrorists’ capabilities, and it limits India’s regional leadership.
India’s position on shared rivers
River systemIndia’s positionCurrent issue
Indus (with Pakistan)UpstreamTreaty in abeyance; routine data-sharing stopped; Chenab-Beas link tunnel approved
Brahmaputra (with China)DownstreamChina restricting data while building the Medog dam
Ganga/Padma (with Bangladesh)UpstreamIndia has protested Bangladesh’s proposed Padma Barrage

Static Dimensions

  • SCO: founded in 2001; India and Pakistan became full members in 2017; the Regional Anti-Terrorist Structure (RATS) is in Tashkent.
  • Indus Waters Treaty (1960): India has the eastern rivers (Ravi, Beas, Sutlej); Pakistan has the western rivers (Indus, Jhelum, Chenab), with India allowed limited non-consumptive uses such as run-of-river hydropower. India has placed it “in abeyance”; a Court of Arbitration ruled in 2026 that it remains in force, which India does not recognise.
  • Regional frameworks: SAARC has been largely inactive since 2016; BIMSTEC is an alternative. India follows a “Neighbourhood First” policy.
  • Law: the 1997 UN Watercourses Convention (India is not a party); the principle of equitable and reasonable utilisation.

Analysis

  • Upstream and downstream: India is upstream of Pakistan and Bangladesh but downstream of China; positions it takes with neighbours can be mirrored back by China, so a rules-based approach to rivers serves its long-term interest.
  • Climate pressure: glacial melt and floods make data-sharing and early warning common needs.
  • Multilateral platforms: SCO meetings offer a contact channel without formal bilateral talks, and can build issue-specific cooperation on disaster management and climate.
  • Compartmentalising: the editorial favours separating security from low-politics issues, as seen among rivals elsewhere. The counter-view is that cooperation without action on terrorism rewards a state that has not changed its behaviour, and that India’s leverage lies in conditionality.
  • Regional leadership: a convening role requires engaging difficult neighbours, but must not compromise core security concerns.
  • Caution: both sides’ positions are firm, and any opening depends on political decisions in both capitals.

Challenges

  • Terrorism, trust deficit and hostile rhetoric.
  • Weak legal framework for rivers after the treaty was put in abeyance.
  • China’s upstream role and data restrictions.

Way Forward

  • Use the SCO and similar platforms for limited, functional cooperation (climate, disaster, health) without diluting India’s stance on terrorism.
  • Resume hydrological data-sharing on humanitarian grounds and for flood warning.
  • Work towards basin-wide frameworks involving China and Bangladesh.
  • Revive sub-regional cooperation through BIMSTEC and others.

India Implications

  • Security: any engagement must leave India’s firm stance on cross-border terrorism intact.
  • Water diplomacy: consistent, rules-based positions protect India as a downstream state on the Brahmaputra.
  • Regional leadership: multilateral fora let India shape the regional agenda without formal bilateral talks.
ConclusionA firm position on terrorism and practical cooperation on shared resources need not be in conflict. Selective, rules-based engagement through multilateral fora can protect security while sustaining regional leadership.
Mains Practice

“India’s firm position on cross-border terrorism and its interest in regional cooperation need not be mutually exclusive.” Critically examine this statement in the context of India-Pakistan relations. (15 Marks, 250 Words)

↑ Back to contents

Raman Academy · North Oak, Sanjauli, Shimla 171006 · 7649911100

Raman Academy ✕